Batch Record Review SOP: GMP Procedure and Checklist

Batch Record Review (BRR) SOP

A batch record review SOP defines how authorised personnel verify manufacturing, packaging and quality control records before a batch disposition decision. A complete, traceable review confirms that personnel followed approved instructions, results meet specifications, and reviewers assessed discrepancies. This practical procedure is a template: adapt it to your site’s quality system, product type and applicable market requirements.

1. Purpose and scope

This standard operating procedure (SOP) describes the controlled review, documentation, escalation and approval of executed batch production and control records. It applies to paper and electronic records for manufacture, processing, packaging, labelling, in-process controls and associated laboratory testing. It covers records from issuance or generation through review, resolution of discrepancies, batch disposition and archival.

2. Responsibilities

  • Production and packaging: complete records contemporaneously, accurately and legibly; identify and report errors or deviations promptly; provide supporting records when requested.
  • Quality Control (QC): review laboratory and in-process results, calculations, specifications, instrument records and associated investigations; report out-of-specification or atypical results through approved procedures.
  • Quality Assurance (QA): coordinate the review, assess completeness and compliance, document findings, resolve discrepancies or document their formal disposition, and approve the record where authorised.
  • Qualified Person or other authorised disposition role: perform any separate certification or release duties required by the applicable licence and quality system. A batch record review approval does not automatically replace these duties.
  • Document control or records management: maintain controlled access, version history, retrieval, retention and archival arrangements for completed records.

3. Batch record review procedure

3.1 Retrieve and identify the record set

First, obtain the complete executed batch production and control record, including the approved master instructions or applicable version reference, packaging records, sampling records, laboratory results, equipment and area logs, material issue and reconciliation records, and approved attachments. Confirm the product, batch number, strength or presentation, manufacturing site, record version and page or electronic-record sequence. Record the reviewer and review date in the approved system.

3.2 Batch record review: check completeness and GDP

  • Check that required steps, entries, pages, attachments, initials, signatures and dates are present and attributable to trained personnel.
  • Confirm entries are legible, made at the time of the activity, and use approved units, formats and controlled forms.
  • For corrections, verify the original entry remains readable, the reason is recorded where required, and the correction is dated and attributable. Do not accept unexplained overwriting, backdating or use of correction fluid.
  • For electronic records, review audit trails and metadata when required by procedure; confirm access, changes and electronic signatures are attributable and appropriately controlled.

3.3 Batch record review: verify approved instructions

Next, compare recorded operations with the effective master batch record, manufacturing instructions, packaging instructions and approved procedures. Confirm that critical process parameters, times, temperatures, set points, equipment identification, line clearance, environmental conditions and in-process controls were recorded and remained within approved limits. Check that any permitted adjustment or reprocessing step was authorised and documented before use.

3.4 Batch record review: reconcile materials and yields

Then verify material names, codes, lot numbers, status, quantities issued and quantities used. Review actual and theoretical yields against approved limits, and assess any unexplained loss, excess, rework or rejected material. For packaging operations, check printed component issuance, reconciliation, destruction or return, line-clearance records and the correct product and batch details on labels and packaging records.

3.5 Batch record review: review QC results

In addition, confirm that the team completed required sampling, in-process testing and finished-product tests using approved methods and specifications. Verify results, calculations, units, acceptance criteria and approvals. Confirm that out-of-specification, out-of-trend or invalidated results have an approved investigation and documented impact assessment. Do not treat repeat testing or a passing retest as a substitute for an adequate investigation.

3.6 Assess deviations and discrepancies

Identify missing data, conflicting entries, procedural departures, alarms, unplanned events and specification failures. Check that each issue is recorded in the appropriate deviation, laboratory investigation or non-conformance system; that scope, root cause, product and other-batch impact, corrective action and required approvals are addressed; and that the record cross-references the investigation. Place the batch on hold when required by procedure. An unresolved or unexplained discrepancy must not be closed by informal annotation.

3.7 Document findings and approve

Record the review outcome using the approved checklist or electronic workflow. Describe each finding clearly, link it to the relevant page, step or data item, and route it to the responsible function for correction or investigation. Verify the response and evidence before closure. When review is satisfactory, sign and date the record as required. If issues remain open, document the hold or escalation and do not indicate final approval.

4. Batch record review checklist

  • Correct product, batch number, record version and complete record set.
  • All required steps, entries, pages, attachments and authorised signatures present.
  • Entries contemporaneous, attributable, legible and corrected according to GDP.
  • Equipment, area, line clearance and material status documented as required.
  • Process parameters and in-process controls within approved limits or fully investigated.
  • Material, yield, reject and label reconciliation complete and within approved criteria.
  • QC results, calculations, specifications and laboratory approvals reviewed.
  • Deviations, OOS/OOT results and discrepancies investigated with impact assessed.
  • Required corrective actions completed or appropriately controlled before disposition.
  • Review findings, batch hold status, approval and archival location documented.

5. Record retention, training and controlled templates

File approved records and related investigations in the validated or otherwise approved records system. Retain, protect and retrieve them for the period required by applicable regulations, product licence commitments and site procedures. Personnel who prepare, review or approve batch records must be trained on this SOP, relevant GDP requirements, record systems and escalation pathways before performing the task. Document training and assess competence as defined by the site quality system.

Use a controlled checklist or form that captures batch identification, review sections, findings, cross-references, review outcome, reviewer identity and date, and final approval. Maintain the template under document control; do not use an uncontrolled copy as the official record.

6. Definitions

  • Batch record: the approved and executed production, packaging and control documentation for a specific batch.
  • GDP: good documentation practices that support accurate, complete, consistent and traceable records.
  • OOS/OOT: out-of-specification or out-of-trend result, handled under the applicable investigation procedure.
  • Batch disposition: the authorised decision to release, reject or otherwise control a batch after required reviews and certifications.

7. Frequently asked questions

Who should review a pharmaceutical batch record?

Designated, trained reviewers should review records according to the site quality system. In the United States, 21 CFR 211.192 assigns review and approval of production and control records to the quality control unit before batch release or distribution. Other markets have their own requirements and release responsibilities.

Can a batch be released with an open deviation?

Only if the applicable procedure and authorised quality decision allow it, with the issue assessed, justified and controlled. A critical or unexplained discrepancy must be escalated and investigated; reviewers should not assume that an open deviation is acceptable or that a passing test alone resolves it.

Does batch record approval equal final batch release?

Not necessarily. Record review is one required quality activity. Final disposition, certification or release may require additional checks or a separate authorised role, depending on the product, licence and market.

For related guidance, see the SOP for batch record reconciliation.

8. Regulatory references

Use the current requirements applicable to the product and market. Relevant sources include 21 CFR 211.192, Production record review; the FDA’s Questions and Answers on CGMP Requirements—Records and Reports; and the European Commission’s EudraLex Volume 4 GMP guidelines, including relevant documentation and production chapters. Confirm the current version and local implementation before adopting this template.

This example is for general information and must be reviewed, approved and adapted by the organisation’s authorised quality personnel before use as a controlled SOP.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *